UBSS6023 Business Ethics Case Analysis Sample
For information and reference only – not to be submitted as your own work.
This UBSS6023 sample shows how one case section of a group case analysis can be built for the module Business Ethics, Responsibility and Sustainability. It follows the section pattern in the UBSS6023 Assignment 1 group case analysis brief: background, key issues, ethical theories, alternatives, a recommendation and an implementation plan. For the method behind each step, read our guide on how to write a UBSS6023 BERS case analysis.
How this extract is set up
The full assignment covers four cases in one report of 4,000 to 6,000 words, so each case receives roughly 700 to 1,000 words. This extract shows one case, Case 3 (Jextra Neighbourhood Stores), at that scale, then a short comparative note. The case text is not reproduced here. The scenario below is an illustrative assumption built to show the method: a neighbourhood retail chain under margin pressure has to choose between a cost-saving measure that weakens service and safety standards and a slower, more costly route that protects them. Replace every assumed fact and figure with the facts and figures in your own case file.
| Brief section | Suggested words per case | What markers look for |
|---|---|---|
| 5.1 Background and situation | 100–150 | Own-words summary, named decision-maker, the decision to be made |
| 5.2 Key issues | 120–180 | One clear dilemma, root causes, ethical versus legal versus managerial concerns |
| 5.3 Ethical theories | 250–350 | Two or three theories that disagree, applied with case evidence |
| 5.4 Alternatives | 150–200 | At least two options compared on stakeholders, reputation, finance and sustainability |
| 5.5 and 5.6 Recommendation and plan | 150–250 | A justified choice, risks, owners, dates and indicators |
Case 3 (illustrative): Jextra Neighbourhood Stores
5.1 Case background and situation
Jextra is treated here as a chain of neighbourhood convenience stores serving mainly local households, with a small head-office team, store managers and a base of independent suppliers. Rising supplier prices and rent have squeezed margins. The main decision-maker is the chief executive, who must decide whether to approve a cost-reduction package that cuts staffing hours per store and moves purchasing to cheaper suppliers with weaker quality checks, or to protect standards and accept a lower profit for a time. Each assumption in this paragraph should be replaced by the facts in your case.
5.2 Identification of key issues
The central dilemma is whether short-term margin recovery justifies passing risk on to customers, employees and suppliers. Secondary issues include fair treatment of workers, honest dealing with suppliers and the chain’s reputation in the communities it serves.
The root causes are managerial and structural: thin margins, limited bargaining power and a performance system that rewards cost savings but does not measure service quality. The concerns are not all of one kind. Food safety and labour rules are legal and regulatory matters, whereas the question of whether it is right to shift risk to people who cannot easily refuse it is ethical. Treating these as separate layers shows the marker that you can tell what the law requires from what responsible conduct requires (Carroll, 1991).
5.3 Critical analysis and application of ethical theories
Utilitarianism. Mill (1863) judges an action by its consequences for overall welfare. A utilitarian analysis counts the benefits of the cost package, such as preserved jobs at head office, a lower risk of closure and stable prices, against the harms: longer queues, a greater chance of unsafe stock reaching shelves, and lower pay and morale for store staff. The theory is useful because it forces numbers and probabilities into the discussion. Its weakness is that a small chance of serious harm to a few customers can be outweighed on paper by a large, certain gain for many, which most managers would find unacceptable.
Deontological ethics. Kant (1785/1997) holds that some duties bind regardless of outcomes and that people must be treated as ends in themselves, never merely as means. Applied here, the company has a duty to sell goods that are safe and honestly described, and to treat workers and suppliers fairly. Cutting inspection to save cost fails this test because customers are not told that the risk has risen. The theory gives a firm boundary, but it does not say how to choose between two duties that conflict, for example duty to staff jobs and duty to customer safety.
Stakeholder theory. Freeman (1984) argues that managers must balance the legitimate claims of everyone affected by the firm, not only shareholders. Donaldson and Preston (1995) add that stakeholders have intrinsic value, so their claims are not just a means to profit. Mitchell, Agle and Wood (1997) help to rank claims by power, legitimacy and urgency. In this case customers hold high legitimacy and urgency, store staff hold high legitimacy and moderate power, and suppliers are less powerful but are exposed to the sharpest price pressure.
| Theory | Likely verdict on the cost package | Main limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Utilitarianism | Acceptable only if the safety risk is shown to be very small and savings protect many jobs | Probabilities are hard to estimate and minority harm can be outweighed |
| Deontological ethics | Rejected where it hides risk from customers or treats staff and suppliers as mere means | Does not resolve conflicts between duties |
| Stakeholder theory | Modified: pursue savings that do not fall on the most exposed stakeholders | Gives no formula for balancing claims |
The three theories disagree in a useful way. Utilitarian reasoning might tolerate the package, duty-based reasoning rejects its hidden risk, and stakeholder reasoning points to a compromise. A strong answer explains why the group sides with the third view and still keeps the other two as checks.
Need a second reader for your own case sections? Our case study help in Malaysia team can review your structure and theory application before you submit.
5.4 Evaluation of alternatives
| Option | Advantages | Disadvantages | Stakeholder and sustainability impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Approve the full cost package | Fast margin recovery; simple to implement | Higher safety and service risk; staff turnover; reputational damage if an incident occurs | Harms customers, staff and weaker suppliers; weak long-term sustainability |
| B. Reject cuts and keep current standards | Protects trust and safety | Margins keep falling; closure risk for weak stores | Protects stakeholders now but may not be financially sustainable |
| C. Phased savings that protect safety, with supplier partnership | Savings from waste, energy and shared purchasing; keeps inspection and staffing floors | Slower payback; needs management attention and some investment | Balances claims; supports a stable supplier base and a lasting brand |
5.5 Group recommendation and justification
The group recommends Option C. It is the only option that passes the duty-based test, respects the most urgent stakeholder claims and still improves profit. The financial case is weaker in year one than Option A, but a single serious safety or labour incident can cost more than the savings, in fines, lost sales and damaged trust. Risks remain: savings may take longer than planned, and suppliers may not accept joint purchasing. The board should therefore set a review date and agree in advance which measures would trigger a return to the board for a new decision. Good governance also means the board, not only the chief executive, owns this decision, in line with the board oversight of sustainability risk that the Malaysian Code on Corporate Governance 2021 encourages (Securities Commission Malaysia, 2021).
5.6 Implementation plan
| Action | Owner | Timeline | Indicator |
|---|---|---|---|
| Set minimum staffing and inspection standards per store | Operations director | Month 1 | Audit pass rate, queue time |
| Launch waste, energy and shared-purchasing savings programme | Finance and procurement leads | Months 1–6 | Cost per store against baseline |
| Agree supplier standards and payment terms through dialogue | Procurement lead | Months 2–4 | Supplier retention, delivery quality |
| Introduce a confidential reporting channel for staff concerns | HR manager | Month 3 | Reports received and closed |
| Board review of results and ethics indicators | Board and audit committee | Month 6, then yearly | Customer complaints, staff turnover, margin trend |
Comparative note across the four cases
When your report moves from the individual cases to the comparative section, look for patterns rather than repeating each case. In many business ethics cases the common thread is a performance system that rewards short-term results while ethical risk goes unmeasured. The differences usually lie in who bears the harm and whether the law already covers it. Link these patterns to ethical leadership, accountability and stakeholder responsibility, as the brief asks, and finish with two or three lessons a manager could apply elsewhere.
Want to check your four-case report before the group submits it? Our MBA assignment help for postgraduate students page explains how our team can help, and you can send your brief through our assignment submission form.
References
- Carroll, A. B. (1991). The pyramid of corporate social responsibility: Toward the moral management of organizational stakeholders. Business Horizons, 34(4), 39–48.
- Donaldson, T., & Preston, L. E. (1995). The stakeholder theory of the corporation: Concepts, evidence, and implications. Academy of Management Review, 20(1), 65–91.
- Freeman, R. E. (1984). Strategic management: A stakeholder approach. Pitman.
- Kant, I. (1997). Groundwork of the metaphysics of morals (M. Gregor, Trans.). Cambridge University Press. (Original work published 1785)
- Mill, J. S. (1863). Utilitarianism. Parker, Son and Bourn.
- Mitchell, R. K., Agle, B. R., & Wood, D. J. (1997). Toward a theory of stakeholder identification and salience: Defining the principle of who and what really counts. Academy of Management Review, 22(4), 853–886.
- Securities Commission Malaysia. (2021, April 28). SC updates the Malaysian Code on Corporate Governance to promote board leadership and oversight of sustainability. https://www.sc.com.my/resources/media/media-release/sc-updates-the-malaysian-code-on-corporate-governance-to-promote-board-leadership-and-oversight-of-sustainability
Prepared by
Malaysia Assignment Help Editorial Team
This model answer was prepared by our editorial team in response to a real assignment brief we received. It shows one way to approach the task and is meant as a study guide, not for submission.
